In Part 1 we made the case that there is no single most sustainable coffee bag, only the right bag for your beans and the disposal bin your customer can actually access. We covered the four things worth weighing up, why barrier still counts, and how to read past the labels and the greenwashing.
This part is where it gets practical. We look at where the rules are heading, then we put every structure we make on the table with a sustainability rating, so you can compare them honestly and choose with your eyes open.
The rules are changing, and they will shape the way you package your coffee
Packaging is shifting from a nice to have sustainability story into a compliance question with money attached. Here is roughly where things stand.
Australia
The national packaging targets asked for all packaging to be reusable, recyclable or compostable, with more recycled content and an end to problematic single use plastics, by 2025. Progress has fallen short and those targets will not be met on time. In response, the Australian Packaging Covenant Organisation has been consulting on a stronger, industry led approach to extended producer responsibility. The direction of travel is clear. Packaging producers, which includes roasters and packers, will carry more responsibility for what they put on the market. Designing now around recycled content and genuine recyclability is the safe bet.
The REDcycle gap.
When REDcycle collapsed in late 2022, Australia lost its national soft plastic collection scheme almost overnight, and recovery has been slow and patchy since. New programs are being built and investment is coming back, but for now soft plastic recovery depends heavily on where your customer lives. This is exactly why mono material and kerbside ready options have become so important.
United Kingdom.
If you export, the UK now has extended producer responsibility with real teeth. Producers must report their packaging and, from 2025, submit recyclability assessments that grade each design red, amber or green. From the 2026 to 2027 year, the fees they pay are modulated by that grade, so easy to recycle packaging costs less and hard to recycle packaging costs more. Mono material and high recycled content designs are rewarded directly.
United States.
There is no single federal scheme, but a growing patchwork of state laws is pushing in the same direction, favouring recyclable and recycled content packaging. If you sell into several states, designing for recyclability now hedges against that fragmentation.
The common thread runs through all of it. Mono material with recycled content is where regulation is heading almost everywhere, which makes it both the more sustainable choice and the more future proof one.
How we rate our range
Our sustainability score out of 5 looks at how likely a bag is to be recovered where your customers actually live, and how much recycled or renewable material goes into it. Overall circularity feeds in as well. Oxygen barrier sits beside it as a separate score, because, as we covered in Part 1, a bag that lets your coffee spoil creates waste of its own.
A quick note before the numbers. These ratings are our own assessment. They are a guide to help you compare, not a substitute for checking what your own customers can recycle or compost where they are.
The range, rated out of 5

Mono PCR Soft Plastic. A single plastic family with post consumer recycled content. Because it is one family rather than several laminated together, it carries far more value in the recycling stream and opens up recovery options that mixed plastic cannot. Best for roasters who want a long shelf life with the strongest recyclability story in a plastic format. The catch is that it costs more than mixed plastic, and soft plastic recovery still varies by region while collection rebuilds after REDcycle.
Mixed Soft Plastic. The traditional high performance pouch. Excellent protection at the keenest price, with effectively unlimited print and add ons like a ripper zipper, which is why it has been the industry workhorse for years. The honest downside is end of life. It is laminated from several plastics, so it is not kerbside recyclable. It can still go through smaller soft plastic recycling schemes, but we usually point roasters towards mono as the better long term home.
Kerbside Recyclable Kraft Paper. A heavy duty kraft paper bag, assessed under the ARL to go straight in the household yellow bin. It works within the recycling system almost every Australian already has at home, which means it actually gets recovered rather than relying on a scheme that may not exist locally. No valve needed, because it lets your coffee degas naturally. Best for cafe retail and local sales where coffee turns over quickly. Just note that paper lets more oxygen through, so shelf life is shorter, and it is worth asking customers to decant into an airtight jar at home.
Home Compostable High Barrier. Our most popular bag, and for good reason. It is a kraft and plant based structure with a high barrier compostable layer, certified home compostable, finished with a resealable zipper. It is the closest thing we make to having it both ways, strong protection alongside a genuinely circular end of life. It is the priciest structure we make, though plenty of roasters still find it well within reach.
Reusable Airtight Canister. The next frontier, and still in development. The idea is a loop. A subscription customer receives a canister with their first order, then gets their weekly coffee posted in a kerbside recyclable refill. Reuse beats recycling and composting because nothing has to be remade each cycle. It is not on general release yet, so talk to us if you would like to be part of the early work.
Why there is no single best bag
Notice that no structure necessarily wins on every front. Plot protection against planet and the bags spread out rather than lining up behind one winner. Home Compostable High Barrier and Mono PCR sit up in the strong corner, getting you close to protecting the coffee and the planet at once. Kerbside kraft paper trades a little shelf life for the easiest, most accessible end of life going. The reusable canister, once it launches, will sit furthest into that corner of all.
That spread is the whole point. The “best” bag is the one whose trade offs match your business.
How to choose the right bag
The single most useful habit is to design for the bin your customer actually has, not the one you wish they had. A brilliant compostable bag is wasted on someone who will never compost it, and a recyclable bag only counts if the collection exists locally.
So start at the end. Work out where the bag will realistically finish up, and the rest tends to fall into place.
– If your customer will put it in the **household yellow bin**, Kerbside Recyclable Kraft Paper is your friend.
– If they **compost at home**, Home Compostable High Barrier gives you that without sacrificing shelf life.
– If your route is **soft plastic recovery**, Mono PCR Soft Plastic carries the strongest recyclability story in a plastic format.
Once you know where it ends up, the barrier, the format, the freight and the price all sort themselves out far more quickly.
A few things you can do right now
- Match the structure to your customer and their waste stream.Whether that is kerbside kraft paper, mono with recycled content or home compostable, the trick is knowing where it will end up and designing for that.
- Educate your customers. If you use paper, ask people to decant into an airtight jar so the coffee stays fresh. If you go compostable, tell them how and where to compost it. Clear instructions close the loop.
- Push for better systems. Back the return of soft plastic collection and community composting in your area. Real change needs supply and demand pulling in the same direction.
- Talk to us. We will help you weigh the trade offs honestly and land on the right fit.
Let’s talk it through
EcoBarista is a certified B Corporation, making sustainable coffee packaging for roasters and cafes across Australia. We are not at the finish line and we do not pretend to be. The gaps in recycling and composting infrastructure are real, and the honest way forward runs through suppliers, roasters, cafes and customers chipping away at it together. What we can promise is straight talk and packaging that performs. If you would like a hand matching a structure to your coffee, get in touch for a quote and we will walk the options with you.
Missed the first half? Head back to Part 1 to understand the rationale and thinking that formed the basis of this article.